Johnson and Johnson Johnson child powder containers are displayed on a shelf on July 13, 2018 in San Francisco, California.
Justin Sullivan | Getty Pictures
A federal choose on Friday dismissed Johnson & Johnson's request to return roughly 2,400 courtroom instances for its talcum powder to a Delaware district courtroom, referring instances to state courts.
J & J requested to switch the information, which allege that his child powder contained asbestos and prompted ovarian most cancers and different cancers, from state courts to a Delaware district courtroom, after his talc provider Imerys, who had himself sued, had already filed for Chapter 11 safety in Delaware this 12 months.
In a ruling on Friday, Justice Maryellen Noreika mentioned the Delaware Federal Court docket had no authority over the lawsuits towards J & J just because the J & J supplier had filed for chapter. Noreika additionally said that J & J had did not take authorized motion towards the corporate, however was immediately affecting Imerys and its chapter procedures.
"The judges of states which can be already coping with these instances are higher in a position to hear petitions earlier than them than this Court docket, which ought to hear hundreds of instances and implement totally different nationwide legal guidelines," she mentioned. declared.
This denial leaves J & J on the mercy of dozens of various courts and judges. State courts have to date yielded combined ends in the J & J case. A Missouri jury ordered the corporate to pay $ four.69 billion to 22. ladies who had alleged that her talcum powdered child powder contained asbestos and prompted them ovarian most cancers.
"We’re disillusioned with this determination, which might have simplified the method of reviewing present instances and improved the general effectivity of all events concerned," mentioned a spokeswoman for J & J in an announcement. .
The corporate mentioned its place that child powder is "secure and doesn’t trigger most cancers has not modified" and that it’ll proceed to "vigorously defend" its merchandise in courtroom.
J & J faces greater than 14,000 lawsuits alleging that its child powder can be on the origin of ovarian most cancers and mesothelioma.
WATCH: "We predict unequivocally that our child powder doesn’t include asbestos," mentioned Johnson & Johnson's chief govt